1. it was the right size but had a 2000# axle.
2. it had the 3500# axle but the trailer itself was too wide and/or long.
3. it was what I wanted, but was $1200+.
Regardless of the trailer, I wanted it to have the same 5x5 bolt pattern so I could buy 3 more matching tires and share them with my Jeep (especially the spares).
I finally found one that I thought it would work. It was a home made trailer that was 4'x6' and was told it had a 3500# axle. Possibly... it looked beefy and had a 6x5.5 bolt pattern. It had large leaf springs and coil springs. The height was perfect for my Jeep and I wouldn't have to lift it. I found a company that makes a 2" spacer that will adapt the bolt pattern to the 5x5 I need, plus give me a little wider stance. These billet 6061 aluminum spacers are about $60 each.
The concern I had was that the trailer seemed to have been built by a lazy person. The coil springs are welded to the axle and the trailer tub. The U-bolts that held the axle to the leaf springs were also welded in place. The tailgate wasn't lined up perfectly, so there is a small gap. The sheet metal side walls had holes where the fenders use to be mounted. He cut out the welds that held he fender and bolted them higher to allow for the lift. The sheet metal he used on the bottom wasn't welded in properly and there is an obvious hump in the middle. Lastly, there was a lot of surface rust in the trailer.
Overall, very crude, but functional. I took it out on Sunday and went wheeling to a shooting spot. The trailer did very well. I only paid $450 for it, and it does what I need.
So, now I am torn. Do I fix all these errors and spend more $$$ making it perfect, or should I just live with what it is... a crude functioning trailer.
At the minimum, I plan on removing all the pain/rust from the inside, re-weld the sheet metal flooring, then paint/roll the inside with Herculiner.
Here are some pics.















