My don't waste your money contribution.
Feel free to add yours or tell me that you like horrible movies and hate America.
Squid in the Whale
Rotten Tomato Failure
Worst scene: library semen wipe
A Single Man
Another RTFU
Despite having gay undertones (sarcasm) the movie is a little depressing too (more sarcasm)
A Serious Man
Don't worry you won't feel much for the obscure j'actors especially since there is no resolve to any malformed story.
Lymelife
See above description but add real actors
Burn After Reading
I got Shyamalan'd on this one in the theater as the Cohen brothers tossed watchers their first FU (second would be the Serious title above).
Best scene would be Malkovich with the Axe but that could fit any of his roles